The Swamp

AB_skin_test wrote:It's an arguable stance to say that there is no bigger Eric Clapton fan in the swamp than me, but the original Layla isn't even one of my top 10 Clapton songs.

I get tired of Layla halfway through the song, but if this thread was "Greatest fucking opening guitar riffs of all time", Layla is a solid top 5 contender.

Last couple of times I went home to DE, 'MMR had added in too much modern stuff for my tastes.

WMGK last played "Dreams" this past Saturday.

Clapton, I'd go something from Cream. White Room, Born Under A Bad Sign, or Crossroads (aware last two are covers, but they are bad ass.)

Maybe not proud to admit this, especially here with all the Swamp music snobs, but when someone mentions "the song 'Dreams'", this is the first that comes to mind:

L-Jam3 wrote:Maybe not proud to admit this, especially here with all the Swamp music snobs, but when someone mentions "the song 'Dreams'", this is the first that comes to mind:

I guess you skimmed the thread like 'fluff (though the previous reference was a little subtle).

Yeah, I generally stay out talking in music discussion threads. My basic belief with music has always been that the underlying goal for any musician isn't to tell their views or promote their art, but rather ultimately to get pussy (or cock). So to argue who's better at their pussy-getting ways seemed like a waste. Not saying anyone's wrong with being a music snob, it was just never something that really got me overly excited; different strokes for different folks.

AB_skin_test wrote:It's an arguable stance to say that there is no bigger Eric Clapton fan in the swamp than me, but the original Layla isn't even one of my top 10 Clapton songs.

Big fans of any band or musician never like that artist's most popular stuff. That doesn't mean that Layla still isn't Clapton's most anthemic song. I'm not even sure what his #2 would be. Maybe Cocaine or White Room.

yeah. But it should be clarified that I love Layla, too. There are probably about 30 songs with Clapton as the lead guitarist (Which is my definition of a Clapton song since he has iconic stuff with Cream and Derek & The Dominos -WMGGW is excepted as a Beatles song), that I like better than even "sweet Emotion" but that doesn't mean they all would be what I consider a great classic rock radio song. The layla cut without the extended piano is pretty excellent though as a radio single.

A big reason for that is a lot of my favorite Clapton cuts are off live discs where he has extended solos. Bell Bottom Blues off 24 nights being the prime example...the album cut is nothing compared to that live version, which I simply adore, darling.

If more Fleetwood Mac sounded like this I'd be into them

Jerloma wrote:So fluff has me on ignore, apparently.

Nope. I admitted that I only skimmed, though.

devilfluff wrote:

Jerloma wrote:So fluff has me on ignore, apparently.

Nope. I admitted that I only skimmed, though.

No, I know. Although admittedly, I don't post a youtube video like the rest of these douchebags. OTHAFA doesn't need to be heard; only revered.

How does the Swamp feel about Creedence Clearwater Revival?

Fortunate Son and Travelin' Band are both amazing classic rock songs.

But are they classic rock?

Weatherfrog wrote:How does the Swamp feel about Creedence Clearwater Revival?

Fortunate Son and Travelin' Band are both amazing classic rock songs.

But are they classic rock?

I think CCR is definitely classic rock.

I like Down on the Corner

I agree.

I included "radio" in the title for a reason, and anything that gets regular play on a "classic rock" station is fair for consideration. Except it's 2014 and NYC's primary classic rock station regularly plays OMD (good song, not classic rock) and Green Day (nonono).

Fired up that 24 nights live double album just now. God what a great show.

Always loved this song.

For when we branch out to the classic rock radio driving songs...

rass wrote:For when we branch out to the classic rock radio driving songs...

I'm gonna put that in the top 5 driving songs of all time.

rass wrote:For when we branch out to the classic rock radio driving songs...

Agreed. Great driving song.

and I'll enter this as one the best songs no one has heard.

and had no idea Golden Earring are Dutch.

Radio plays some forgotten song; Brenda Lee's Comin' On Strong:




Little Miss Dynamite!

Back in the olden days, when I used to ski a lot, I had a ritual of listening to Radar Love right before my first run of the day. Great bass line.

That's extreme.

Here's one. Although it isn't a single. And is too long for most radio formats. But it is classic, it does fucking rock, and it is great:

Gunpowder wrote:I'm thinking Comfortably Numb but not in love with it as current #1.

Comfortably Numb is definitely one of the best. Obviously, this is all subjective, but Gilmour is my favorite rock guitarist ever. Speaking of guitarists, I'll cast my vote for best classic rock song ever for Voodoo Child (Slight Return).

This won't be a popular take, but I'm not much of a Pink Floyd fan and never was. I grew up in the classic rock era and thus heard tons of Pink Floyd. I can appreciate their artistry and production, but to me they aren't really a rocking band, and generally, I want to hear something else.

sancarlos wrote:This won't be a popular take, but I'm not much of a Pink Floyd fan and never was. I grew up in the classic rock era and thus heard tons of Pink Floyd. I can appreciate their artistry and production, but to me they aren't really a rocking band, and generally, I want to hear something else.

I'll plus one on this.

+2. They're fine, but I don't ever think...man I wanna fire up some FLoyd.

AB_skin_test wrote:+2. They're fine, but I don't ever think...man I wanna fire up some FLoyd.

High school rass used to think that.

Though I can't find it, or it's been lost to the Swamps of time, I've told the story of the long, cross country trip I took with my parents that is one of my earliest memories. To this day, both Baker Street and Miracles are songs that make me think of highways and a hot, vinyl backseat.*

I heard Miracles on the radio yesterday. In typical me fashion, I've never bothered (until this morning) to read up on the song despite the fact that it's randomly meaningful to me, so I didn't know there was a radio cut and an album cut of the song. The radio single version was edited not just for time, but for content. Specifically this, I guess:

I had a taste of the real world (Just a drop of it)
When I went down on you, girl, oh.

I noticed that line yesterday, and it stood out so much that I'm not entirely sure that I've ever actually heard the album cut. The lyrics as transcribed here read like a horrible love poem, and then there is this towards the end:

(sarcastic Grace mini-orgasm)

*If I had to pick one for actual inclusion in this thread, it would be Baker Street

Comfortably Numb probably has my single favorite guitar solo ever.

rass wrote:

I had a taste of the real world (Just a drop of it)
When I went down on you, girl, oh.

Yeah, this came out in 75, and they would play the album version regularly on radio. About that time I gave up on Starship.

Here's a nominee for the category, just came on radio. Although arguably only the second best from this artist for this category.

For the haters. Hint: it's not the Eagles

" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

I'm not a fan of the Dead per se, but that is a good song.

If anyone has ever driven from New Orleans to Houston with an awful hangover, they'll know that the Dead are full of shit on that song.

Giff wrote:If anyone has ever driven from New Orleans to Houston with an awful hangover, they'll know that the Dead are full of shit on that song.

That line is in reference to the band getting busted in New Orleans, and having to pay almost 40K to get everyone out of jail.

BSF21 wrote:

AB_skin_test wrote:It's an arguable stance to say that there is no bigger Eric Clapton fan in the swamp than me, but the original Layla isn't even one of my top 10 Clapton songs.

I get tired of Layla halfway through the song, but if this thread was "Greatest fucking opening guitar riffs of all time", Layla is a solid top 5 contender.

Currently listening to the Derek & The Dominos album "The Complete Jams" I think any of these are better than Layla, and I bet George Harrison would agree. :)

Fun thread. Here's another nominee (yes, black people rock classically)

" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

howard wrote:Fun thread. Here's another nominee (yes, black people rock classically)

" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Based on your introductory comment, I was SURE that was going to be Sly and the Family Stone.